Home › Knowledgebase › KB-1229

Microsoft 365 security audit checklist for insurance

Summary

This guide helps you troubleshoot and resolve: Microsoft 365 security audit checklist for insurance. Follow the steps below to fix the issue.

Quick Tip: Need immediate assistance? đź’» Open a Ticket

Common Causes

Cyber insurance providers across Australia are tightening their requirements for small business coverage. Whether you are applying for a new policy or renewing an existing one, insurers often request documented evidence of your IT security posture before offering coverage. Common requests include proof of Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA), conditional access policies, antivirus deployment, and application patch management. Microsoft 365 Business Premium includes the tools needed to meet these requirements, but you need to know where to find the reports and how to present them. This checklist helps Australian small business owners prepare for cyber insurance audits without last-minute panic.

Quick Fix Steps

  1. Log in to the Microsoft 365 admin centre using an account with Global Administrator or Security Administrator privileges.
  2. Confirm MFA is enabled for all user accounts, especially privileged administrator accounts.
  3. Review Conditional Access policies in Microsoft Entra ID to ensure sign-in risk requirements are enforced.
  4. Verify Microsoft Defender for Business is active and devices are reporting healthy status.
  5. Export the Secure Score report and save it as a CSV or PDF for your insurance provider.
  6. Document your patch management process for operating systems and Microsoft 365 apps.
  7. Map your current controls to the ACSC Essential Eight maturity model.
  8. Attach the exported reports and policy documents when responding to your insurer’s questionnaire.

Detailed Instructions

1. Verify Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA)

Insurers typically require MFA for all users, particularly those with administrative access. In Microsoft 365 Business Premium, you can check this through the Microsoft Entra admin centre.

  1. Go to https://entra.microsoft.com and sign in with an administrator account.
  2. In the left navigation, select Identity, then choose Users.
  3. Select All users and review the authentication methods for each account to confirm MFA is registered.
  4. For any user without a registered authentication method, select the user and choose Authentication methods to add MFA.
  5. Prioritise enabling MFA for Global Administrator, Exchange Administrator, and SharePoint Administrator accounts first.
Tip: If your organisation uses security defaults, MFA is already enforced for all users. You can confirm this under Properties in the Microsoft Entra admin centre.

2. Review Conditional Access Policies

Conditional Access allows you to require MFA based on sign-in risk, location, or device compliance. This is often specifically requested by cyber insurers.

  1. In the Microsoft Entra admin centre, select Protection from the left menu.
  2. Choose Conditional Access.
  3. Review existing policies to ensure they apply to all cloud apps and require MFA for high-risk sign-ins.
  4. If no policies exist, select New policy and create a baseline policy requiring MFA for all users.
  5. Set the policy to Report-only initially to analyse sign-in impact before enforcing it.

3. Check Microsoft Defender for Business Status

Managed antivirus and endpoint protection are standard insurance requirements. Microsoft Defender for Business is included with Microsoft 365 Business Premium.

  1. Go to the Microsoft 365 Defender portal at https://security.microsoft.com.
  2. Select Endpoint from the left navigation, then choose Device inventory.
  3. Confirm that all business devices are listed and show a healthy onboarding status.
  4. Review Incidents & alerts to ensure there are no unresolved critical threats.
  5. Export the device health report as a PDF to attach to your insurance application.

4. Export Your Microsoft Secure Score

Secure Score provides a measurable snapshot of your security posture and is useful evidence for insurers.

  1. In the Microsoft 365 Defender portal, select Secure score from the left menu.
  2. Review your current score compared to the average for organisations of your size.
  3. Select Export to save the report as a CSV. For a PDF version, use the browser print function to save the Secure Score page as a PDF.
  4. Note any improvement actions marked as Planned or In progress and document expected completion dates.

5. Document Patch Management

Insurers want to see that operating systems and applications are kept up to date. Microsoft 365 Business Premium includes update management capabilities through Microsoft Intune.

  1. Go to the Microsoft Intune admin centre at https://intune.microsoft.com.
  2. Select Reports, then choose Updates to view update compliance.
  3. Alternatively, select Endpoint security and then Update policies to manage deployment rings.
  4. Review update rings for Windows 10/11 and Microsoft 365 Apps.
  5. Confirm that feature updates and quality updates are deployed within a defined timeframe appropriate to your organisation’s risk tolerance.
  6. Export the update compliance report for your records.
Tip: Enable automatic updates for Microsoft 365 apps via the Microsoft 365 admin centre under Settings > Org settings > Microsoft 365 apps.

6. Align With the ACSC Essential Eight

The Australian Cyber Security Centre (ACSC) Essential Eight is frequently referenced by Australian insurers. Use it as a framework to document your controls. Note that patching timeframes vary by maturity level; critical vulnerabilities at higher maturity levels may require patching within 48 hours, while other maturity levels allow longer windows such as two weeks.

7. Document Security Awareness Training

Insurers commonly request evidence that staff have completed security awareness training. Maintain records of training completion, including dates, topics covered, and which users participated. If you use a training platform, export completion reports to attach to your insurance application.

Caution: Do not make security changes solely to satisfy an insurer without first testing the impact on business operations. Enforcing Conditional Access or MFA without pilot testing can lock users out of critical applications and cause disruption. Apply changes to a small test group first, review sign-in logs, and then roll out to the wider organisation.

Troubleshooting

MFA Is Not Showing as Enabled for Some Users

If MFA appears disabled for certain accounts, check whether those users are excluded from security defaults or Conditional Access policies. Review exclusions under Protection > Conditional Access > Named locations and Users in the Microsoft Entra admin centre. Re-enable MFA at the user level if necessary, then re-export the report.

Devices Are Not Appearing in Defender for Business

Devices missing from the device inventory are likely not onboarded to Intune or Defender for Business. Confirm that the user’s device is enrolled in Intune and that the device compliance policy is assigned. Reinstall the Microsoft Defender for Endpoint agent if the device remains offline.

Secure Score Export Fails

If the export option is unavailable or the file does not download, confirm that your administrator account has Security Reader or Global Reader privileges. Try exporting as a CSV instead of PDF, or use your browser’s print-to-PDF function on the Secure Score page. Clear your browser cache and retry if the page fails to load.

Patch Reporting Gaps in Intune

If update compliance reports show missing devices or outdated status, verify that the devices are enrolled in Intune and receiving policies. Check that update rings are assigned to the correct device groups. Allow up to 24 hours for devices to report status after policy changes, then regenerate the report.

Insurer Questionnaire Response Guidance

When completing your insurer’s questionnaire, answer based on your documented security posture rather than aspirational goals. Attach the exported Secure Score report, Conditional Access policy screenshots, MFA coverage evidence, patch compliance reports, backup verification logs, and security awareness training completion records. If a control is not yet implemented, note the planned implementation date rather than marking it as complete.

Next Steps

Once you have gathered your evidence, submit it with your insurance application or renewal documents. Keep copies of all exported reports and screenshots in a secure folder for future audits. Review your security posture quarterly to ensure continued compliance with your insurer’s requirements. If you need assistance exporting reports or configuring Conditional Access policies, Open a Ticket.

Still Having Issues?

Need more help? If the issue persists after trying these steps, please open a support ticket and our team will assist you.

đź’» Open a Ticket