Home › Knowledgebase › KB-1071

How to Set Up Microsoft Authenticator Number Matching to Stop MFA Fatigue Attacks on Your Microsoft 365 Account

Summary

This guide helps you troubleshoot and resolve: How to Set Up Microsoft Authenticator Number Matching to Stop MFA Fatigue Attacks on Your Microsoft 365 Account. Follow the steps below to fix the issue.

Quick Tip: Need immediate assistance? 💻 Open a Ticket

Common Causes

Microsoft Authenticator number matching is a security feature that protects your Microsoft 365 account from MFA fatigue attacks. Instead of simply tapping "Approve" on a push notification, you must enter a two-digit number shown on your sign-in screen into the Microsoft Authenticator app. This extra step confirms that you are actively authorising the login and prevents attackers from spamming you with approval requests until you accidentally accept one.

Important: Number matching is enforced by your organisation's IT administrator or managed service provider. You cannot turn it on yourself from the Microsoft Authenticator app or your Microsoft 365 account settings. If you do not see a number prompt when signing in, your administrator may still be rolling out the feature, or your organisation may not have the required Microsoft 365 or Microsoft Entra ID licensing in place.

What Is an MFA Fatigue Attack?

An MFA fatigue attack happens when someone obtains your password and repeatedly sends sign-in approval requests to your phone. The attacker hopes you will become annoyed or confused and tap "Approve" to make the notifications stop. Number matching stops this attack because the person attempting to sign in does not know the two-digit number displayed on your screen, and you should only enter that number if you initiated the login yourself.

Licensing and Small Business Context

Number matching requires appropriate Microsoft 365 or Microsoft Entra ID licensing, such as Entra ID P1 or P2, or a qualifying Microsoft 365 business plan. Not all small business plans include this capability by default. If you are a small business owner without a dedicated IT staff member, speak with your IT support person or managed service provider about enabling number matching through Microsoft Entra ID authentication methods. They can confirm whether your current licensing supports the feature and configure it for your organisation.

Add Your Account to Microsoft Authenticator

  1. Download Microsoft Authenticator from the Apple App Store or Google Play Store.
  2. Open the app and tap Add account.
  3. Select Work or school account.
  4. Use your phone's camera to scan the QR code displayed during your Microsoft 365 sign-in setup, or sign in with your work email and password when prompted.
  5. Allow notifications when asked so you can receive sign-in prompts.
Do not uninstall or reinstall Microsoft Authenticator without guidance from your IT administrator or managed service provider. Removing the app can break your MFA registration and may lock you out of your Microsoft 365 account.

Use Number Matching to Sign In

  1. Sign in to your Microsoft 365 account on a computer or browser using your email and password.
  2. When prompted, look for the two-digit number shown on your computer screen.
  3. Open the notification on your phone or open the Microsoft Authenticator app.
  4. Enter the matching two-digit number in the app.
  5. Tap Yes to complete the sign-in.

Verify Number Matching is Active

  1. Sign out of your Microsoft 365 account on a browser.
  2. Sign back in with your email and password.
  3. Confirm that a two-digit number appears on your computer screen.
  4. Enter the number in the Microsoft Authenticator app on your phone.
  5. Tap Yes to approve the sign-in.

If you are asked to simply tap "Approve" without entering a number, number matching may not yet be enabled for your account. Contact your IT support person or managed service provider to confirm the status.

Report Unexpected Prompts Immediately

Never approve a number matching prompt that you did not initiate. If you receive a sign-in request on your phone when you are not trying to log in, someone may have your password. Change your Microsoft 365 password immediately and report the suspicious activity to your IT support team or managed service provider. You can also Open a Ticket for assistance.

Troubleshooting

I am not receiving push notifications

  • Check that your phone has an active internet connection using mobile data or Wi-Fi.
  • Ensure notifications are enabled for Microsoft Authenticator in your phone settings.
  • Disable battery optimisation or low power mode for the Microsoft Authenticator app on Android devices.
  • Confirm that your phone is not in Do Not Disturb or Focus mode.

The number on my screen does not match the app

  • Make sure you are entering the two-digit number shown on the device you are signing into, not a code from another authenticator app.
  • Refresh the sign-in page and request a new prompt.
  • Close and reopen the Microsoft Authenticator app.

I am still being asked for a simple Approve button

  • Confirm your organisation has enabled number matching for your account.
  • Contact your IT support person or managed service provider to review your Microsoft Entra ID authentication methods and security settings.
  • Do not remove and re-add your account unless advised by your administrator, as this may break your MFA registration.

My phone is lost, stolen, or broken

  • Contact your IT support person or managed service provider immediately so they can remove the lost device from your Microsoft 365 MFA settings.
  • Request a temporary authentication method or assistance registering a new device.
  • Change your Microsoft 365 password as a precaution if the phone was stolen.
  • You can also Open a Ticket for urgent assistance.

I have a new phone or new device

  • Contact your IT support person or managed service provider before setting up Microsoft Authenticator on your new device.
  • Your administrator may need to clear your existing MFA registration or issue a temporary access pass.
  • Download Microsoft Authenticator from the Apple App Store or Google Play Store on your new phone.
  • Follow your administrator's instructions to add your work or school account and complete registration.
  • Test the setup by signing out and back into your Microsoft 365 account to confirm number matching works.

I am locked out of my account

  • Contact your IT support person or managed service provider to verify your identity and reset your authentication method.
  • You can also Open a Ticket to request account recovery assistance.
  • Do not attempt to bypass MFA using unofficial methods, as this may delay recovery and create security risks.

Still Having Issues?

Need more help? If the issue persists after trying these steps, please open a support ticket and our team will assist you.

💻 Open a Ticket