How to Set Up Microsoft 365 Number Matching in the Authenticator App to Prevent MFA Fatigue Attacks
Summary
This guide helps you troubleshoot and resolve: How to Set Up Microsoft 365 Number Matching in the Authenticator App to Prevent MFA Fatigue Attacks. Follow the steps below to fix the issue.
Common Causes
Overview
Microsoft Authenticator number matching is an authentication method policy managed at the Microsoft Entra ID tenant level by your organisation’s IT administrator. It is not a setting you can switch on or off inside the Microsoft Authenticator app.
When number matching is enabled, signing in requires more than simply tapping Approve on a push notification. A two-digit number appears on the device you are signing in from, and you must enter that exact number into the Microsoft Authenticator app on your mobile device before tapping Yes to complete authentication.
This process prevents MFA fatigue attacks, where attackers repeatedly send push approval requests in the hope that a user will accidentally accept one out of frustration, habit, or confusion. Because the user must actively read and enter a number, accidental or unauthorised approvals are significantly less likely.
Prerequisites
Before number matching can be used, the following conditions must be met:
- Licensing: Your organisation must have a licence that supports authentication method policies, such as Microsoft Entra ID P1 or P2, or Microsoft 365 Business Premium, E3, or E5 (or equivalent).
- Admin enablement: Your IT administrator must enable number matching in the Microsoft Entra admin center under Protection > Authentication methods > Microsoft Authenticator. There is no user-facing toggle in the Authenticator app.
- MFA registration: Your user account must already be registered for Microsoft Entra multifactor authentication.
- App installation: The Microsoft Authenticator app must be installed on your iOS or Android device.
- Account added: Your work or school account must already be added to the Microsoft Authenticator app.
- Push notifications: You must be using push notifications for authentication. Number matching does not apply to one-time passcode (OTP) verification.
- App unlock or biometrics: On some devices, you may need to unlock the app or have biometric authentication configured before you can enter the number.
What you experience during sign-in
- Enter your work or school email address and password on the sign-in page.
- A two-digit number appears on the screen of the device you are signing in from.
- Open the Microsoft Authenticator app on your mobile device.
- If prompted, unlock the app or complete biometric authentication.
- Enter the exact two-digit number shown on your sign-in screen.
- Tap Yes to complete the sign-in.
Troubleshooting
Number matching prompt is not appearing
- Confirm with your IT administrator that number matching has been enabled for your user account or organisation in the Microsoft Entra admin center.
- Ensure you are using the Microsoft Authenticator app and not a third-party authenticator app.
- Check that your mobile device has an active internet connection.
- Verify that you are authenticating with push notifications, not an OTP code.
- If the policy was recently enabled, try signing out and back into your account within the app, or re-register the Microsoft Authenticator app if cached credentials are causing issues.
App is not receiving notifications
- Verify that notifications are enabled for the Microsoft Authenticator app in your phone settings.
- Ensure your device is not in Do Not Disturb or Focus mode.
- Check that your device has an active mobile data or Wi-Fi connection.
- Try signing out and back into your account within the app.
Still seeing the old “Approve” flow
- Contact your IT administrator to confirm that number matching is enforced for your account and that the previous notification approval method has been disabled.
- Remove and re-add your account in the Microsoft Authenticator app to refresh the authentication method.
Security warnings
Getting help
If you are unable to complete sign-in or experience ongoing issues with Microsoft Entra multifactor authentication, Open a Ticket with our Brisbane support team.
Still Having Issues?
💻 Open a Ticket